May 10, 2008
Elaine Meinel Supkis
A reader kindly sent me a story about the latest MIT/Abu Dhabi project to build an entire city that runs on only renewable resources. My parents went to the Arabian countries during the late 1960's and until the late '70's to help start up SOLARAS, the Solar Energy Research center there. This was because they persuaded the kings of Saudi Arabia to prepare for the future and to beware of the Hubbert Oil Peak. So now this sort of work is rapidly expanding with the foundation of this new, research city. The US should be doing this at home except there is still too little interest. We will also visit a Greenpeace model community in England.
From a 1981 Aramco newsletter:
The utilization of solar energy in Saudi Arabia began in 1 960 when a French company installed a Photovoltaic powered beacon at a small airport. The research activities commenced with small scale university projects during 1969. The first large solar project was the construction of the world's largest solar heating system for a school in the late seventies. The systematized work in solar energy research and development was not genuinely inaugurated until King Abdulaziz City for Science and Technology (KACST) was established in 1977.
*snip*
One program, that is called SOLERAS (Solar Energy Research-American/Saudi), addressed solar energy technological and economical related issues. SOLERAS was established in 1975 and concluded in 1997. A second program started as of 1 989 with DOE (Department of Energy in the United States), addresses in addition to solar energy R&D, the other technologies of renewable energy.
My parents got involved in persuading the Arab rulers who were sitting on the biggest oil reserves on earth, to go into renewable energy research. This, when the Arabs were first seeing the benefits of higher oil prices and greater oil production. The various programs that were launched have had a checkered history due to lack of genuine fear on the part of the oil kingdoms concerning their future. But now that they a finally seeing their own Hubbert Oil Peak right before their own eyes, the interest in setting up a better system is growing more urgent by the day. When my parents came to Saudi Arabia, most of the people there lived in rather primitive conditions. For example, once there was a big rain storm and millions of bugs came pouring into the apartments where my mother was staying, covering all the walls with creepy-crawlies.
Today, the cities in Arabia are some of the most sophisticated on earth. But as King Faisal said about living in tents in the desert, moving into cities and eventually returning to the camels and the tents, the bounty from the oil profits can be fleeting. As with the high oil prices in the seventies and eighties, all this nearly vanished in the 1990's and Saudi Arabia nearly went bankrupt. Overspending on silly things while making zero preparations for the loss of oil profits, the entire enterprise nearly went under. This is why there is a lot of nervousness over there today. They know the profits can vanish along with the savings and investments. The US has tried to spook Saudi Arabia into supporting extravagant oil consumption over here in order to save their investments in our businesses and properties. But they are obviously going to just cut their losses.
The urgency to develop a sustainable energy community is growing rapidly in the Middle East. Incidentally, another country that made it very clear they were interested in developing sustainable energy systems back in the seventies was China. My parents went there to work on similar projects which are still very much ongoing today. Only here, in America, was their message about the Hubbert Oil Peak and sustainable energy rejected by the government and incidentally, with the election of Reagan, the US voters.
Even today, I see very little movement towards programs that will retrofit our nation for a sustainable energy future! McCain and Clinton both want to make gasoline, the poison that is killing us, cheaper! By cutting taxes that keep our infrastructure from collapsing. And Obama has said little about any of this. All, very sad. Today, I think we should visit the Masdar Initiative project being launched by Abu Dhabi as well as some other, similar energy projects in Europe and Israel.
Last week, in the harsh desert climate of Abu Dhabi, construction started on a city that will house 50,000 people and 1,500 businesses but use extremely little energy, and what it does use will come from renewable sources. The initial building is a new research institute that the founders hope will be the seed for the equivalent of a Silicon Valley of the Middle East, only one centered not on information technology but on renewable energy.The city, which is expected to cost $22 billion, will implement an array of technologies, including thin-film solar panels that serve as the facades and roofing materials for buildings, ubiquitous sensors for monitoring energy use, and driverless vehicles powered by batteries that make cars unnecessary. Indeed, the city's founders hope that it will serve as a test bed for a myriad of new technologies being proposed to reduce greenhouse-gas emissions.
The new zero-emissions city, which is being built near the city of Abu Dhabi in the center of the United Arab Emirates (UAE), is part of the Masdar Initiative, a $15 billion government-funded investment program designed in part to ensure that the UAE's prosperity won't be linked exclusively to its oil. Its leaders say that the project will give the country a leadership position in renewable energy. If it's successful, says Sultan al Jaber, Masdar's CEO, "we'll be sitting on top of the world."
Here are two pictures of what this 'city' will look like:
This proposal has some very nice things only from what I see, they are not going far enough! The project very strongly reminds me of the L-5 Society plans I worked on so many decades ago!
I was involved in many of the debates about the structure of the early L5 proposals. The illustration above was what I called 'suburban space colonies' in that it looked an awful lot like Phoenix, Arizona or Houston, Texas. Surprise, surprise. It was, of course, financially impossible because it was a poor use of materials versus habitat use. Some of us argued that 90% of the habitat space would have to be used for food production facilities. Namely, farming. I even joked that the best space colonists would be Amish farmers! Then we had to figure out how to get them out to a space colony and decided to pretend they were being kidnapped by aliens. Heh.
But seriously, the proposals for the model city here leaves me cold due to a lack of greenery. The oxygen/humidity/psychological benefits should be obvious. Plants filter pollution and these places have indoor pollution up the yin yang. Also, the Garden of Eden aspect should not be ignored. I keep two small trees and a number of bushes and potted plants indoors in winter here for these reasons. Who wants to live in what looks like a mall with a food court? The other thing that bothers me in general about Abu Dhabi is the mania for tower building. Towers are not energy efficient buildings. They are grandiose expressions of human hubris. The energy consumption of elevator use not to mention the maitenance problems of big towers is not sufficiently appreciated. True, the Empire State Building has endured a long, long time. Even being hit by a plane. But it is much smaller in floor space than post-WWII towers and has a much, much higher ratio of solid masonry material per square foot.
But the systems being set up in Abu Dhabi's experimental city is very similar to the L-5 Space Colony proposals. For human waste, water use, cooling and heating systems are all going to be bio and energy sustainable. And this is a good concept which all cities should have. Indeed, I proposed long ago, we should move all our manufacturing and cities to space and turn the planet earth back into the Garden of Eden for evolution and living things to recolonize it and continue their amazing evolutionary history! It would also remove us from the grave dangers of weather, earthquake and volcanic hazards. Not to mention bigger events like ice ages, for example. Then the earth could be a vacation spot to feel the force of gravity and enjoy viewing the wonders of nature, etc. Sigh.
is a non-profit, independent entity established with the assistance of the world- renowned Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), under a cooperative agreement signed in December 2006. MIT is assisting the Masdar Institute to emulate its own standards of excellence in Abu Dhabi, and to become a regional engine for technology-driven growth by combining local cutting-edge research with high-caliber graduate education.The Masdar Institute offers Masters and PhD programs in Science and Engineering disciplines designed to attract top-level talent from local and international universities. Masdar Institute students and researchers will experience uniquely-rewarding opportunities in the region's emerging sustainable energy and technology industries, through continual interaction with top academics and campus-based industry experts. Combined with solid scientific training, such experience will ensure that Masdar Institute graduates are in high demand, both regionally and internationally.
MIT is very near where I live, about 1 1/2 hours away. I hope some time to visit their offices and learn more. We should be grateful that the Arabs have chosen this joint venture and perhaps we will gain something from all this. The belief that the present set up we enjoy in America will be our future lifestyle is impossible. So we should start thinking hard, what will we replace it with? I suggested years ago that most suburbs without train service will be turned into scavenger zones and habitat for bears and wild birds in 50 years or less. When we travel about the Midwest, we can see abandoned Victorian farm houses left over from the days when it took an army of people to farm. As modern equipment took over human and horse labor, the percentage of farm labor in the population collapsed from over 60% to under 6%. So it is with our suburbs: they will be just as abandoned.
I once owned a very lovely Victorian mansion. It was very expensive to maintain and to run. The energy use, in particular, was great. So it is with our cultural system of suburban housing. I like the idea, in the Abu Dhabi city, of electric cars, hopefully able to run on a maglev system, picking up people. Instead of the constant headache of owning a car, one can travel in comfort while not worrying about dealing with break downs, insurance, etc. I know many humans love cars as extensions of their egos but that is childish and would be rather silly in the future, I would hope.
There are other, better ways to 'strut your stuff.'
A blueprint for no carbon footprint
MIT will maintain a close association with the Masdar Institute, whose faculty will spend a year here before beginning their teaching there. But the involvement with the creation of the new city and campus is more limited.Some of the initial ideas for the zero-energy plan came from the MIT collaboration, says Leon Glicksman, professor of building technology and mechanical engineering and director of MIT's Building Technology Program. "We did work with them when they were evaluating proposals for the architecture," he says, but now "they're on a really fast track for construction," so the British architectural firm, Foster + Partners, which did the principal design work, is taking the lead.
Once the project is built, MIT will have an ongoing role in monitoring the actual energy performance of the city, Glicksman says. And that could provide an extraordinary opportunity for students to learn about the potential for such large-scale integrated approaches to innovative energy production and use.
Years and years ago, in the Ice Ages, when MIT was being built [heh] I went to an L-5 meeting there. The new building we met in was in the cement Architecture Brutality style monstrosity which was supposed to be 'modernism' at that time. Moving beyond the Bauhaus Box style, these things looked like cement pill boxes from WWII. I decided to liven it up and drew a unicorn on the wall with a pen. It still didn't fix the psychological depressed state of the building. So I hope the people advising the Abu Dhabi project are not detached from the historic ideal for a place where humans should live: the Hanging Gardens of Babylonia. One of the Seven Wonders of the World according to the ancient Greeks.
Here is an old article from back when the US and others were very worried about energy, from the Jimmy Carter era:
A "solar pond" is an attempt to solve one of the more difficult problems associated with solar energy: how to collect it. Though sunshine falls on the peninsula in massive quantities, no one has yet perfected a way of conserving it efficiently, and the Research Institute hopes that what they call a "salt gradient" solar pond, may provide a solution.Essentially, a solar pond is, in the words of the solar program's acting director Bruce Nimmo, "just water, salt, a hole and a liner." The hole is scooped out of "sabkhas," the salt flats which abound the eastern coastal region of Saudi Arabia, then lined with plastic and filled with salt water, found, usually just below the surface.
What happens then, however, isn't at all as simple. Based on certain principles concerning the loss of heat from liquids and gasses, the water in a solar pond gets hotter and hotter and can be stored without loss of the heat.
Normally, in ponds, lakes or seas, the water, when it is heated by the sun, loses the heat at the surface through convection - roughly defined as movement in the water caused by temperature, density and gravity factors. But if the water is heavily salted, the movement of the heated water at the bottom of the pond or lake is restricted by the high density caused by the high salinity. As a result, the convection principle - i.e. the loss of heat at the surface caused by movement - no longer operates effectively; to the contrary, the water in the bottom half of the pond gets hotter and hotter; in the solar pond temperatures can go as high as 212 degrees F, enough to boil an egg or, more practically, provide hot water for dishwashers, showers, and washing machines in homes.
*snip*
So far, the institute's modest experiments - with a prototype pond built at the institute's solar lab last fall - have been successful; a meter and a half deep (five feet) and saturated with salt in its bottom half, the pond, built above ground, registered a temperature of 129 degrees F in its "lower convecting zone" or salt-saturated region just two weeks after start-up. In sufficient volume, water at that temperature could be pumped out of the pond's lower half and piped to homes and buildings for heat, or to factories, for such industrial purposes as washing bottles in a bottling plant.The Research Institute, however, has more ambitious goals. Its scientists want to use solar ponds to generate electricity - by heating water to about 200 degrees F in the pond - pumping it out and transferring the heat in the water to a fluid with a lower boiling temperature (a Freon, for example) which, as it vaporizes, could drive a turbine.
From a 1980 publication: ISRAEL'S 150-KW SOLAR POND
One of the most impressive sights of the entire excursion was a small power-generating station located at the southern end of the Dead Sea. . . where a considerable amount of electricity is being produced, using solar energy. You might well assume that the plant operates on photo-voltaic's, but—if that's what you're thinking—you'll have to guess again. The new power-generating facilities are solar ponds. . . inexpensive, often naturally occurring phenomena that may just hold the secret to a safe and reliable, middle-technology form of energy production!Needless to say, MOTHER is very interested in any power system that delivers a lot for a little. So—in addition to reporting on what we saw in Israel—we fully intend to research, first hand, the possibility of scaling down both the size and technology of the operation . . . in order to put it on the "little guy's" level, and maybe open up a whole new world of energy independence for us all!
The Israelis were, from the very beginning, interested in developing alternative energy systems. But unlike the Abu Dhabi or Saudis, they couldn't simply fund it themselves. Hand out time, as usual. But the system of using very salty water which they had in a great quantity via the Dead Sea, as an energy boosting system is smart. Certainly, this can be set up in much of the equatorial countries not to mention Australia. The hopes of this system seem to not have been as great as we wanted back then. But the technology continues to evolve.
The energy obtained is in the form of low grade heat of 70 to 80 °C compared to a 20 °C ambient temperature, which has an upper Carnot-cycle extractable efficiency of 1-(273.15+20)/(273.15+80)=15%. By comparison a solar concentrator system with molten salt delivering high grade heat at 800 °C would be able to convert 73% of absorbed solar heat into useful work, and be forced to divest only 27% as waste heat to the cold temperature reservoir (ambient air).Further research is aimed at addressing the problems, such as the development of membrane ponds. These use a thin permeable membrane to separate the layers without allowing salt to pass through.
Usually, these sorts of systems don't take off unless there is tremendous urgency. I recall the seventies: the reason the alternative energy proposals as well as the L-5 Society took off back then was due to stark fear. It wasn't the inflation or the high prices, it was the RATIONING of energy that got people hopping. Since 1980, there has ben zero rationing. Even as people get increasingly hysterical about pricing, there are still no lines unless a gas station wants publicity and drops prices a few pennies. Then, people rush over and stand in line for an hour for a $2 savings. Pathetic, isn't it? Even in the ration years, I didn't bother to stand in any gas lines. I considered it a waste of precious time.
Right now, I see people wanting things to simply be cheaper. I see now realization that this is yet another shot across our prow and we better get working on changing all our systems! Mr. Kunstler does go about the nation, lecturing on all this. But this preaching to the choir. It has not penetrated much further. We can only pray that the US public wakes up before it is too late.
Here is a Greenpeace-sponsored energy efficient community in England:
Bedzed is a 100 home eco-village in South London which uses state of the art energy efficiency techniques to create a 'zero emission' community.
In the end, it is all about comfort. Before I was born, nearly no one lived with air conditioning. And central heating was a city thing and certainly not universal. In Pasadena, my god mother and my grandfather both used these gas heaters that were very ancient that heated up only the room they were in. I loved watching the blue/yellow flames warm up the ceramic grille until it would glow a bright red! But it was very simple. My own Victorian house in Tucson was heated the same way in the sixties. The addiction to 'comfort' is tremendous and totally modern. Just 2 generations ago, it barely existed even for kings and queens. The drafty palaces of the royals are still very drafty today!
And here are some other energy systems that are interesting:
Schmack BioEnergy (SBE) is an anaerobic digestion company located in Cleveland, OH. SBE is partnered with Schmack Biogas, the leading German anaerobic digestion technology with over 250 plants in operation. Schmack BioEnergy's first plant in the United States is in Akron, OH processing 5,000 dry tons/year of municpal biosolids
If we wish to cling to the comforts and joys of modern life as it has developed in only the last 50 years and for only the top 20% of humanity, we have to make some sacrifices today. Are we willing to do this? History shakes her snake-like locks and smiles.
For photos of concrete housing construction from around the world visit http://picasaweb.google.com/ConcreteForming
Posted by: Carl Engelken | May 14, 2008 at 12:19 PM
For photos of concrete housing construction from around the world visit http://picasaweb.google.com/ConcreteForming
Posted by: Carl Engelken | May 14, 2008 at 12:19 PM
Hi there! It was wonderful to read your post, I especially loved all the pictures and video clips that went along with it. Looks like that area of the middle east is really booming, especially with all that money from oil being poured into their new mega metropolis. I would love to in somewhere like Dubai! In my wildest dreams I guess, hehehe. I think it's a valiant effort that they are trying to create a whole city based on renewable energy, that would be the most environmentally forward place in the world to live when that happens! I wonder if they plan on using bioheat as a means to counteract the polluting effects of regular oil heat? Has anyone ever heard of bioheat, or are current customers of bioheat? I love it because it is clean burning, costs the same as regular oil heat, uses a b5 blend of oils which includes corn, hemp, and avocados among others.
If you want more info on bioheat then head on over to http://oilheatamerica.com/index.mv?screen=bioheat I work with NORA to bring you this info!
Posted by: Gemina Pearl | May 14, 2008 at 08:59 PM